- Darren Purchese
- Recipes
- Kitchen Notes
Kitchen Notes
- Video Lessons
- Events
- Subscribe
- Merchandise
Flinders Island Crayfish Pie

By Darren Purchese
This is as bougie as it gets, the humble fish pie elevated to icon status. Our final recipe in our Flinders Island series (for now) is this Crayfish Pie. If you have been following along, we visited this pristine island just off Tasmania and while we were there we fished for giant Crays and set to work making delicious recipes. After our efforts on BBQ Crayfish and Crayfish Rolls we had some cooked crayfish meat left over and decided that a pie would be the perfect use for it!
You can use this recipe and substitute the crayfish meat with other seafood including scallops, prawns and fish. If you do get the chance to make this with crayfish, lobster or Moreton Bay bug meat then go for it – you won’t regret your decision.
The pie is rustic in style so there is no pastry base just cooled pie filling in a large tray and topped with the quick flaky pastry. Served family style this would be perfect for a Good Friday get together. Another idea is to make these pies individually as well with pastry bottom and top in little pie tins.
We were lucky enough to be staying at the Crayshack and had plenty of Warrigal greens on our doorstep to forage and add to our pie mix. You could substitute for another green if you prefer such as chard, sliced silver beet or even herbs. Up to you but we couldn’t resist picking our own as it is such a luxury.
The pie is deliberately non cheffy in finish, we were cooking out in the wild, and it was honestly all about the crayfish and the flavour of that fresh seafood with the creamy filling and flaky pie top.
Time to make: 3 hours
Yield: 8 portions
Time
3
hour
0
minutes
Degree of Difficulty
Medium
Save
0
Portions
8
servings
Share Recipe

Ingredients
Servings
metric
imperial
Template is not defined.
Template is not defined.
FLAKY PASTRY
225g unsalted butter, cold diced
360g plain flour
5g salt flakes
140g cold water
1tsp white wine vinegar
PIE FILLING
1.2 kg crayfish meat, cooked
200g leeks, sliced 1 cm, soaked in cold water to purge the dirt
100g celery, peeled and sliced thin
50g Warrigul greens, washed, drained and sliced thin
100g unsalted butter
75g water
50g plain flour
150g white wine
650g milk, whole fat
50g Dijon mustard
1 whole lemon, finely grated zest
½ lemon, fresh juice
1tbsp white wine vinegar
to taste salt flakes
to taste black peppercorns, freshly ground
EGG WASH
60g egg yolks, (approx. 3 large egg yolks)
2tbsp cream, thickened
pinch salt flakes
1
2
For the pastry… cut the butter into 1 cm (1/2 in) dice and chill in the fridge. Put the sifted flour, plus the salt in a mound on your kitchen bench and scatter the chilled butter cubes over the top.
3
Rub in the butter... use your fingertips to rub the butter into the flour until you have a crumbly, sandy texture, with small lumps or shards of butter still visible.
4
Make a well in the middle... add the vinegar to the water. Use a dough scraper or spoon to gently cut the water into the flour until you have a crumbly texture, gathering up any leaks as you do. Use your hands to gently push it all together into a rough dough, with a slightly sticky texture.
5
Rest... roll or press the dough out into a rectangle roughly 3 cm thick. Place the wrapped pastry into a fridge and leave to chill for an hour.
6
To roll the pastry… remove the pastry from the fridge and leave to sit at room temperature on the bench for 5 minutes. Lightly flour the bench and use a rolling pin to roll the pastry out into a sheet with a thickness of 1 cm. Keep lifting the pastry as you roll and use extra flour for dusting to keep the pastry from sticking to the bench. Place the sheet of rolled pastry onto a sheet of baking paper and transfer to a tray. Place the tray into the fridge to chill and rest for 15 minutes before using.
7
For the crayfish meat... break or cut the meat into large chunks and set aside in the fridge on the plate.
8
Drain the leeks... discard the water and any grit. Dab the sliced leeks with a tea towel to dry.
9
Heat a large pan... heat the pan over a medium heat and add in the butter.
10
Cook the leeks... once the butter starts to melt add in the sliced leeks. Season the leeks with a little salt, not too much at this stage. Stir with a wooden spoon or heat-resistant spatula. The leeks need to be cooked for a while so we will manage the heat to make sure they don’t burn.
11
Add the celery next... cook the leeks and celery for two minutes over a medium heat before adding in. the water. Stir again and cook for a further two minutes.
12
Put a lid on it... place a lid onto the pan and cook for a further 3 – 4 minutes, lift the lid and stir well. The vegetables will have wilted down, we need to cook further.
13
Cook with the lid on and off... for a further 10 – 15 minutes to completely soften the veg. We are not looking for colour at this stage of cooking just for the leek/celery to be nice and soft.
14
Once the veg is soft... add the sliced greens. Cook for a further 5 – 6minutes with the lid on or off to soften down again.
15
Put the milk... into a separate pan and heat to warm through. Remove from the heat just prior to scalding. Set aside.
16
Add the flour... once the veg is nice and soft sprinkle in the flour and stir well. The mixture will thicken quickly so stir and turn the heat down a little if you have to (to prevent it sticking to the pan).
17
Cook for two minutes... and stir to fully distribute the flour before adding in the wine. Stir well and cook further. Reduce the wine until it is almost all evaporated.
18
Add the milk... add a third of the milk into the pan and stir well over a medium heat. Cook for one minute further.
19
Add the remaining milk... to the pan and again cook and stir. Bring the mixture to a boil and cook for a minute.
20
Add the mustard... and stir it into the filling.
21
Add the crayfish... to the pan and stir through to heat, re boil and cook for a couple of minutes. Season with salt and pepper.
22
Add the lemon... grate in the zest of a lemon and add the juice of half of it to the pan and stir well. Add the vinegar and stir.
23
Add the filling to a pie dish... you may need to split the mix depending on the size of your dish. Add using a ladle and then refrigerate the dish until cold.
24
For the egg wash... combine the egg yolks, cream and a pinch of salt in a small bowl and whisk with a fork until combined.
25
When the pie filling is cool... remove the pie tin or dish from the fridge. Use a pastry brush to add egg wash to the tope edges of the dish.
26
Add the pastry... add a large sheet of the rolled pastry to the top of the dish. Use your fingertips to press the pastry into the dish. Pinch to seal and trim off any excess.
27
Egg wash... the entire surface of the pie with the egg wash.
28
Decorate with excess pastry... if you like you can add pastry shapes to the surface of your pie, if you do then egg was these as well.
29
Pre heat the oven... to 180C and bake the pie for 30 minutes.
30
Turn in the oven... after half an hour of baking turn the pie around for even cooking. Bake for a further 15 minutes or until the pastry is a golden brown.
31
Serve... in the centre of the table with a green salad.
1
0 hours
0 minutes
2
0 hours
0 minutes
For the pastry… cut the butter into 1 cm (1/2 in) dice and chill in the fridge. Put the sifted flour, plus the salt in a mound on your kitchen bench and scatter the chilled butter cubes over the top.

3
0 hours
0 minutes
Rub in the butter... use your fingertips to rub the butter into the flour until you have a crumbly, sandy texture, with small lumps or shards of butter still visible.
4
0 hours
0 minutes
Make a well in the middle... add the vinegar to the water. Use a dough scraper or spoon to gently cut the water into the flour until you have a crumbly texture, gathering up any leaks as you do. Use your hands to gently push it all together into a rough dough, with a slightly sticky texture.
5
0 hours
0 minutes
Rest... roll or press the dough out into a rectangle roughly 3 cm thick. Place the wrapped pastry into a fridge and leave to chill for an hour.

6
0 hours
0 minutes
To roll the pastry… remove the pastry from the fridge and leave to sit at room temperature on the bench for 5 minutes. Lightly flour the bench and use a rolling pin to roll the pastry out into a sheet with a thickness of 1 cm. Keep lifting the pastry as you roll and use extra flour for dusting to keep the pastry from sticking to the bench. Place the sheet of rolled pastry onto a sheet of baking paper and transfer to a tray. Place the tray into the fridge to chill and rest for 15 minutes before using.

7
0 hours
0 minutes
For the crayfish meat... break or cut the meat into large chunks and set aside in the fridge on the plate.
8
0 hours
0 minutes
Drain the leeks... discard the water and any grit. Dab the sliced leeks with a tea towel to dry.
9
0 hours
0 minutes
Heat a large pan... heat the pan over a medium heat and add in the butter.

10
0 hours
0 minutes
Cook the leeks... once the butter starts to melt add in the sliced leeks. Season the leeks with a little salt, not too much at this stage. Stir with a wooden spoon or heat-resistant spatula. The leeks need to be cooked for a while so we will manage the heat to make sure they don’t burn.

11
0 hours
0 minutes
Add the celery next... cook the leeks and celery for two minutes over a medium heat before adding in. the water. Stir again and cook for a further two minutes.
12
0 hours
0 minutes
Put a lid on it... place a lid onto the pan and cook for a further 3 – 4 minutes, lift the lid and stir well. The vegetables will have wilted down, we need to cook further.
13
0 hours
0 minutes
Cook with the lid on and off... for a further 10 – 15 minutes to completely soften the veg. We are not looking for colour at this stage of cooking just for the leek/celery to be nice and soft.
14
0 hours
0 minutes
Once the veg is soft... add the sliced greens. Cook for a further 5 – 6minutes with the lid on or off to soften down again.
15
0 hours
0 minutes
Put the milk... into a separate pan and heat to warm through. Remove from the heat just prior to scalding. Set aside.
16
0 hours
0 minutes
Add the flour... once the veg is nice and soft sprinkle in the flour and stir well. The mixture will thicken quickly so stir and turn the heat down a little if you have to (to prevent it sticking to the pan).
17
0 hours
0 minutes
Cook for two minutes... and stir to fully distribute the flour before adding in the wine. Stir well and cook further. Reduce the wine until it is almost all evaporated.
18
0 hours
0 minutes
Add the milk... add a third of the milk into the pan and stir well over a medium heat. Cook for one minute further.
19
0 hours
0 minutes
Add the remaining milk... to the pan and again cook and stir. Bring the mixture to a boil and cook for a minute.
20
0 hours
0 minutes
Add the mustard... and stir it into the filling.
21
0 hours
0 minutes
Add the crayfish... to the pan and stir through to heat, re boil and cook for a couple of minutes. Season with salt and pepper.
22
0 hours
0 minutes
Add the lemon... grate in the zest of a lemon and add the juice of half of it to the pan and stir well. Add the vinegar and stir.
23
0 hours
0 minutes
Add the filling to a pie dish... you may need to split the mix depending on the size of your dish. Add using a ladle and then refrigerate the dish until cold.
24
0 hours
0 minutes
For the egg wash... combine the egg yolks, cream and a pinch of salt in a small bowl and whisk with a fork until combined.
25
0 hours
0 minutes
When the pie filling is cool... remove the pie tin or dish from the fridge. Use a pastry brush to add egg wash to the tope edges of the dish.
26
0 hours
0 minutes
Add the pastry... add a large sheet of the rolled pastry to the top of the dish. Use your fingertips to press the pastry into the dish. Pinch to seal and trim off any excess.
27
0 hours
0 minutes
Egg wash... the entire surface of the pie with the egg wash.
28
0 hours
0 minutes
Decorate with excess pastry... if you like you can add pastry shapes to the surface of your pie, if you do then egg was these as well.
29
0 hours
0 minutes
Pre heat the oven... to 180C and bake the pie for 30 minutes.
30
0 hours
0 minutes
Turn in the oven... after half an hour of baking turn the pie around for even cooking. Bake for a further 15 minutes or until the pastry is a golden brown.

31
0 hours
0 minutes
Serve... in the centre of the table with a green salad.

Related Recipes
Pumpkin Finger Buns
Posted by Darren Purchese
Darren's Ghostly Pavlova
Posted by Darren Purchese
Gallery






























More delicious ideas for you
More delicious ideas for you





